Full-scan, data-dependent acquisition (DDA), and data-independent acquisition (DIA) are the three common data acquisition modes in high resolution mass spectrometry-based untargeted metabolomics. It is an important yet underrated research topic on which acquisition mode is more suitable for a given untargeted metabolomics application. In this work, we compared the three data acquisition techniques using a standard mixture of 134 endogenous metabolites and a human urine sample. Both hydrophilic interaction and reversed-phase liquid chromatographic separation along with positive and negative ionization modes were tested. Both the standard mixture and urine samples generated consistent results. Full-scan mode is able to capture the largest number of metabolic features, followed by DIA and DDA (53.7% and 64.8% respective features fewer on average in urine than full-scan). Comparing the MS2 spectra in DIA and DDA, spectra quality is higher in DDA with average dot product score 83.1% higher than DIA in Urine(H), and the number of MS2 spectra (spectra quantity) is larger in DIA (on average 97.8% more than DDA in urine). Moreover, a comparison of relative standard deviation distribution between modes shows consistency in the quantitative precision, with the exception of DDA showing a minor disadvantage (on average 19.8% and 26.8% fewer features in urine with RSD < 5% than full-scan and DIA). In terms of data preprocessing convenience, full-scan and DDA data can be processed by well-established software. In contrast, several bioinformatic issues remain to be addressed in processing DIA data and the development of more effective computational programs is highly demanded.
[dataset license: CC0 1.0 Universal (CC0 1.0)]
Keywords: GNPS Metabolomics MetaboLights
Principal Investigators: (in alphabetical order) |
Jian Guo, University of British Columbia, 2036 Main Mall, Vancouver, BC V6T 1Z1 |
Submitting User: | caceves |
Number of Files: | |
Total Size: | |
Spectra: | |
Subscribers: | |
Owner | Reanalyses | |
---|---|---|
Experimental Design | ||
Conditions:
|
||
Biological Replicates:
|
||
Technical Replicates:
|
||
Identification Results | ||
Proteins (Human, Remapped):
|
||
Proteins (Reported):
|
||
Peptides:
|
||
Variant Peptides:
|
||
PSMs:
|
||
Quantification Results | ||
Differential Proteins:
|
||
Quantified Proteins:
|
||
Browse Dataset Files | |
Browse Metadata | |
FTP Download Link (click to copy):
|